American Horror Storyseason 13 looks set to bring back some huge names, but Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters' return should only happen if it’s the show’s final season. The long-running series started in 2011 and has featured plenty of popular actors over the years. With each season focusing on a fresh, unique story, new additions have joined the cast frequently, while some regulars have come back year after year. While someAmerican Horror Storyseasons connect, others are completely independent, allowing actors to play a variety of different roles and characters throughout their time with the franchise.
Out of everyone who has appeared on the show,Evan Peters and Sarah Paulson have been two of American Horror Story’s most frequently returning actors. They have both played heroes and villains within the chaotic horror universe and, as a result, are two of the most popular actors among the audience. Unfortunately, neither of them has been part of the show since season 10, and their presence has been sorely missed. However,American Horror Storyhas teased Peters and Paulson’s returnin season 13, but this shouldn’t happen unless the series is officially coming to an end.

Sarah Paulson & Evan Peters Should Only Return To American Horror Story If Season 13 Is The Show’s End
American Horror Story Coming To An End Would Justify Paulson & Peter Returning To The Series
AlthoughAmerican Horror Storyremains a flagship show for FX, it has to conclude with season 13 to warrant Peters and Paulson’s returns. The duo has been pivotal to the show’s success, and while some fans still enjoy the horror series, it has been declining in quality for the past few years.American Horror Story’s highest-rated season was season 2:Asylum, showing how long it’s been since the franchise has been at its best. Therefore,bringing these two iconic actors back for just any other season would be a waste, and their return wouldn’t feel special.
Paulson herself has expressed interest in returning but wants to appear alongside Peters, which makes sense since they’ve been involved in exactly the same seasons.

Instead, having them reunite to end the series on a high would be the best way to utilize them. Paulson herself has expressed interest in returning but wants to appear alongside Peters, which makes sense since they’ve been involved in exactly the same seasons and have provided some ofAmerican Horror Story’s best performanceswhile sharing the screen. As a result, bringing them back and connecting their characters would be the best chance of recapturing some of the franchise’s early magic, proving this should be saved for the show’s final season to send it off with a bang.
Why American Horror Story Season 13 Should Focus On Existing Characters
The Show Has Struggled With New Concepts Over The Past Few Years
Despite the show being renewed for a thirteenth season, details are limited onAmerican Horror Storyseason 13’s story, but it should focus on existing characters, much likeApocalypse. AlthoughAHS: Apocalypsewasn’t the franchise’s most successful outing, it was an interesting concept and could have worked under the right circumstances. Seeing old characters share the screen once again was interesting, andif season 13 brought together some classicAmerican Horror Storycharacters for one last outing, it could be one of the show’s most fascinating and memorable seasons, which would be a perfect way to end things.
Please, Ryan Murphy: Make American Horror Story Season 13 The Last One
After the profound failure of Delicate’s finale, American Horror Story season 13 needs to finally bring the anthology show to a long-overdue end.
While season 8 proved it is hard to pull off a story like this,AHScould go all out for the final installment, allowing the ideas to get more creative than ever. The franchise has struggled with new stories for a while now, with1984being the last truly strong season back in 2019, and even the recent spinoff seriesAmerican Horror Storieshas failed to really hit the mark. Therefore, bringing back characters that audiences connected with alongside popular actors like Paulson and Peters would set up an iconic ending, givingAmerican Horror Storythe ultimate farewell.
American Horror Story
American Horror Story is a Horror Anthology series created by Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk. The franchise has seen stars like Connie Britton, Jessica Lange, Denis O’Hare, Zachary Quinto, Evan Peters, and Dylan McDermott. Each season follows a new premise and spans an array of horror genres like witches, ghosts, serial killers, and more.