Arnold Schwarzenegger and Danny DeVito’s buddy comedyTwinsis one of the last 1980s films anyone would expect to get a remake—but it quietly got one all the same with 2024’sBrothers. Though the new comedy starring Peter Dinklage and Josh Brolin isn’t directly related toTwins, the two films share too much in common to ignore. This meant thatBrotherswas a chance to correct the areas in which the original 1988 movie went wrong—but really, neither film was ever set up well to please critics.
Twins(1988) starred Schwarzenegger and DeVitoas unlikely twin brothers who were separated at birth. The former, Julius, was intelligent, gifted, and innocent, while the latter, Vincent, was a short, balding criminal. However, together, they proved themselves to be quite a team. The pair end up on a buddy road trip, resulting in questionable business endeavors while being pursued by those aiming to claim Vincent’s life.Twinsis quirky comedy at its most outrageous, and2024’sBrothershas duplicated much of this to a tee.
Josh Brolin & Peter Dinklage’s 2024 Movie Brothers Is Very Similar To 1988’s Twins
Two Movies From A Similar Mold
The similarities betweenTwinsandBrothershave been clear since the latter film was first announced.They are tonally similar, falling into the heist-crime comedy genre, and both are buddy road trip movies. The characters themselves are similar as well. Brolin is the picture of an action star, but his character’s personality is far quieter and more cautious inBrothers, much like Schwarzenegger’s Julius. Dinklage’s Jady, on the other hand, is the perfect, charismatic, petty criminal who is entirely remorseless, like DeVito’s character inTwins.
Brothers 2024 Soundtrack Guide: Every Song & When They Play In The Movie
A wild mix of songs plays throughout the equally wild road trip heist crime comedy Brothers, which stars Peter Dinklage and Josh Brolin.
Of course,TwinsandBrothersalso have some significant differences. The 1988 movie leaned into the physical differences between Schwarzenegger and DeVito, which served as the film’s primary source of comedy.On the other hand, Brothers allowed the contrast between Brolin and Dinklage’s physicality to remain part of the unsaid nuance while the differences in their personalities took center stage.The critical reception ofBrothershas also improved overTwins, though only slightly.
Why Brothers & Twins Both Have Such Mixed Reviews From Critics
These 2 Comedies Aren’t For Everyone
Twinshas never been remembered as the gold standard of cinema. The movie was supposed to be ridiculous, and it certainly achieved this goal.Schwarzenegger and DeVito’s filmhas a pretty abysmalRotten Tomatoescritic score of 39%, with only a slightly improved audience score of 42%. People either love or hate the quirky comedy, and it’s most certainly not a story or concept that would have been aimed at serious movie critics back in the day. Just asBrothersduplicated aspects ofTwins’s story, it has also duplicated the 1988 film’s reception.
Overall, it’s clear that both these films just aren’t for everyone.
Brothershas left audiences and critics similarly divided. The film has a critic rating of 52% onRotten Tomatoesand an even 50% from general audiences. Those who hated it unsurprisinglypointed their fingers at the lack of character development and originality. However, those who loved it attributed their entertainment to nearly the same things, even addressing the similarities to other similar projects likeTwinsas a benefit. Overall, it’s clear that both these films just aren’t for everyone. However, if the right audiences feel nostalgic forTwins,Brothersmay hit the spot.
Brothers
Cast
Brothers (2024) is a film centered around the complex dynamic between two siblings navigating personal and familial challenges. Directed by nan, the movie explores themes of brotherhood, loyalty, and redemption as the characters confront their past and seek reconciliation.
Twins
Arnold Schwarzenegger and Danny DeVito star in the comedy Twins as Julius and Vincent Benedict, two identical brothers who set out on a road trip to find their biological mother. Directed by Ghostbusters co-creator Ivan Reitman, the 1988 film was a box office success and opened the door for more comedy roles for Schwarzenegger, including Kindergarten Cop, Junior, and Jingle All The Way.
