Warning: this article contains SPOILERS for Abbott Elementary season 4, episode 7While viewers rejoiced at the brief return ofAbbott Elementary, one of the “Winter” episodes highlights a time-sensitive issue with Barbara Howard’s character. Sheryl Lee Ralph’s Barbara has been a staple ofAbbott Elementary’s cast of characterssince the pilot episode, but her character unfortunately hasn’t changed much since then. Barbara has an aversion to change (unless she’s suggesting it), and“Winter Show”puts that hypocrisy on full display. The episode begins with preparations for a Christmas concert, but Barbara decides to make it secular for the sake of one student. As usual, however,Barbara loses sight of what’s important.
In a sense, Barbara’s one-dimensional nature has been helpful, with her staying in the background while larger issues play out, from a student’s father picking a fight with a teacher to ringworm infecting the school. And whileAbbott Elementaryepisodes frequently echo real-life issuesthrough conflict, there’s something to be said about having a stable and downright predictable character. However, withAbbott Elementaryseason 4’s ratingsshowing a clear staying power, it’s time for the show to focus on catching Barbara up to herAbbott Elementarycoworkers instead of recycling her common drawbacks and losing viewers’ interest.
Barbara’s Winter Show Fumble Proves She Hasn’t Grown In Abbott Elementary
Her Heart Starts In The Right Place, But It Doesn’t Stay There
A key tenet of Barbara’s character is her having good intentions but failing to take other people into account. Though her“Winter Show”takeover starts as a thoughtful gesture for her student, it spirals into Barbara insisting on writing her own holiday song for the children to perform in place of the Christmas carol they learned, ignoring how this ruins Janine’s (Quinta Brunson) choreography for the step club. The show is successful in the end, butit’s a success despite Barbararather than because of her, with the students singing their own song after she loses her voice.
While Barbara has been part of some ofthe most heartwarming moments inAbbott Elementary,she’s also been the driving force behind the most frustrating ones.
Abbott Elementaryseason 4 has confronted Barbara with changeenough for her to know better. Barbara ignores her students telling her point-blank what they want to do, simply because it isn’t what she thinks is best. While Barbara has been part of some ofthe most heartwarming moments inAbbott Elementary,she’s also been the driving force behind the most frustrating ones. Sadly,Barbara’s attachment to tradition forces her to make selfish decisionsthat undercut her selfless goals, and the reputation of herAbbott Elementarycharacter suffers because of it.
Abbott Elementary Season 4 Needs To Change Barbara Before It’s Too Late
Barbara Urgently Needs Real Development
That’s not to say that Barbara’s story is without potential, but time is of the essence. While nearly every main cast member has gone through multiple arcs,Barbara has stayed stagnant.The same traits that made Barbara such a lovable character in the first season ofAbbott Elementaryare now making her stale in the fourth, while everyone else gets to explore new, complex aspects of their personalities. For that reason, the series should prioritizea better Barbara storyline inAbbott Elementaryseason 5; if her misguided approach to problem-solving isn’t addressed, the show will miss an opportunity to get the most from Barbara’s character.
Abbott Elementary Season 4 Needs A Big Ava Change To Continue Her Redemption
Abbott Elementary gave Ava a long and necessary redemption arc, but the show is overlooking the perfect way to continue building on that momentum.
It’ll be more difficult to repair Barbara’s character if she stays flat and veers into antagonist territory than to have her truly reflect on her shortcomings and make an effort to improve. The show is banking on what already makes her great, likeBarbara’s memorable quotes inAbbott Elementary, but that devalues her character. At this rate,Barbara is mostly comedic reliefand an occasional obstacle to conquer. If the show opts for another direction, it can deliver a truly memorable storyline for Barbara and evolve her dynamics with some of the other characters.
Abbott Elementaryreturns Wednesday, January 8 on ABC.
Abbott Elementary
Abbott Elementary is a mockumentary comedy series centered around a group of dedicated teachers at a struggling public school in Philadelphia. The show highlights their efforts to overcome bureaucratic challenges and underfunding, while showcasing their commitment to making a positive impact on their students' lives.
